A Case of Metatropic Dysplasia: Operative Treatment of Severe Kyphoscoliosis and Limb Deformities

Hae Ryong Song,¹ Shivam Sinha,^2* Sang Heon Song,¹ and Seung Woo Suh¹

How to cite this article

Song HR, Sinha S, Song SH, Suh SW. A Case of Metatropic Dysplasia: Operative Treatment of Severe Kyphoscoliosis and Limb Deformities. Oman Med J 2013 Nov; 28(6):445-447.

How to cite this URL

Abstract

Metatropic dysplasia is a rare but severe spondyloepimetaphyseal dysplasia characterized by long trunk and short extremities. The exact incidence is not known; however, 81 cases have been reported in the literature till now. Due to progressive kyphoscoliosis, there is a reversal of proportions in childhood (shortening of trunk with relative long extremities). The diagnostic radiographic findings include marked platyspondyly (wafer-thin vertebral bodies), widened metaphyses (dumbbell-shaped tubular bones) and small epiphysis and a specific pelvic shape. The severe kyphoscoliosis is relentless and resistant to conservative treatment with bracing. Operative treatment is controversial due to the recurrence of deformity despite aggressive correction. We, herein report a case of this rare dysplasia and its follow-up after corrective surgery for spine and limb deformity. The excellent correction and good functional pulmonary status at 6-year follow-up has never been previously reported.

Keywords: Kyphoscoliosis; Metatropic dysplasia; Deformity correction.

Introduction

 Metatropic dysplasia (metatropic–changing hypertrophic achondroplasia) was described in 1966 by Maroteaux et al. and presents with characteristic clinical and diagnostic radiographic findings.¹ At birth, children with metatropic dysplasia appear to have a long trunk and short limbs. The relentlessly progressive kyphoscoliosis that occurs during infancy causes an apparent equalization of trunk and limbs, hence the name "metatropic", derived from the Greek word metatropos, meaning "to change." Clinically, most children with metatropic dysplasia are short statured with rhizomelia, prominent stiff joints, pectus carinatum, and severe kyphoscoliosis.

It comprises at least three genetic entities: (1) a nonlethal type with autosomal recessive transmission, (2) a nonlethal dominant type, and (3) a lethal type with death before or shortly after birth and possibly autosomal recessive inheritance.² In addition, the observation of an overlap between the autosomal recessive non-lethal form and the non-lethal autosomal dominant form, the rarity of sibship recurrences and the observation of vertical transmissions of metatropic dysplasia in the literature argue in favor of an autosomal dominant mode of inheritance. Recurrence in sibs is thought to be due to gonadal mosaicism.³ Kyphoscoliosis is usually rapidly progressive after the first 6 months of age leading to alteration of pulmonary function, morbidity and reduced life expectancy. With advancing age, osteoarthritic changes are superimposed on the regressive metaphyseal changes.

Case Report

A 6-year-old Korean male presented with progressive kyphoscoliosis and short stature in the outpatient department (Fig. 1). The first child of an unrelated healthy Korean parents, his antenatal diagnosis could not be obtained. At birth, he was 56 cm (>97 centile) and was noted to have severe kyphoscoliosis, relatively short extremities, and narrow chest with elongated face. Radiographic skeletal survey revealed characteristic vertebra plana (dense wafer thin), dumbbell shaped long bones, kyphosis, halberd shaped pelvis, squared calcaneus and coccygeal appendage consistent with the diagnosis of metatropic dysplasia.

Figure 1: Clinical photograph of the patient presented in OPD showing thoracic kyphosis.

The overall height of the child was 97.5 cm at the age of six years. There was a discrepancy of 4 cm in tibia and 1 cm in femur, with overall limb length discrepancy of 5 cm. The child had a left-sided flexible kyphoscoliosis with Cobb’s angle of 56 degrees on standing X-rays (Fig. 2). After careful preoperative pulmonary function evaluation, corrective spine surgery with posterior fusion with pedicle screw instrumentation from T6 to L4 was done after one year (Fig. 3). Bifocal tibial osteotomy and gradual distraction with Ilizarov ring fixator was done later to improve the short stature and limb length discrepancy as calculated by Green-Anderson chart. The ring fixator was kept for 14 months.

Figure 2: X-ray revealed left sided scoliosis (Cobb’s angle 56 degrees) with abnormalities in pelvis and proximal femur metaphysics.

Figure 3: One year post-op radiograph after corrective spinal surgery and posterior fusion.

At 4 years follow-up of spine surgery, i.e., at 11 years of age, there was no progression of kyphoscoliosis in spine with reasonable pulmonary function and maintained spinal correction. As the child attained the height of 122 cm, there was a limb length discrepancy of 2 cm along with genu valgum of about 10 degrees with medial axis deviation of 33 degrees on right side. This was managed with monofocal femoral osteotomy with gradual lengthening and hemiepiphysiodesis of right proximal tibia (Fig. 4). At final follow-up, the child showed good overall functional improvement orthopedically and socially (Fig. 5). Informed consent was taken from the patient’s parents after explaining the rarity of the disease for using this information for the purpose of publication.

Figure 4: Right-sided medial hemiepiphysiodesis with bilateral femoral distraction for correction of short stature.

Figure 5: Six-year final follow-up with corrected deformities of spine and joints.

Discussion

In the natural course of the disease, the average adult height reaches up to 120 cm. Intellectual development is normal.⁴ The proximal end of femur is club-shaped and the lesser trochanter is prominent and down facing. Dens hypoplasia with C1/C2 instability is a feature in severe case. New radiological features, including precocious calcification of hyoid and cricoid cartilage, irregular and squared-off calcaneal bones and severe hypoplasia of the anterior portion of first cervical vertebra have recently been reported.³ Narrowing of the cervical and thoracic spinal canal may be present, making the corrective spinal surgery more challenging.

The differential diagnosis of such presentation includes other platyspondylic spondyloepimetadysplasias (SMD), especially SMD-Kozlowski and Morquio’s disease (mucopolysaccheroidosis IV). However, none of them show such marked disproportion between the long trunk and short extremities. The radiographic pattern of the spinal, metaphyseal and pelvic changes is unique.

The pathology involved has been studied. The absence of formation of normal primary spongiosa in the metaphysis, the presence of a thin seal of bone at the chondro-osseous junction, with abnormal metaphyseal vascular invasion and arrest of endochondral growth, these findings suggest an uncoupling of endochondral and perichondral growth, and thus, dumbbell-shaped morphological structure of the osseous metaphysis seen in these patients.⁵ Recent research has pointed out that mutations in TRPV4, a calcium permeable ion channel produce a phenotypic spectrum of skeletal dysplasias from the mild autosomal-dominant brachyolmia to SMDK to autosomal dominant metatropic dysplasia, suggesting that these disorders should be grouped into a new bone dysplasia family.⁵ Genetically, this is different for other common dysplasias of bone like milder hypochondroplasia to more lethal thanatophoric dysplasia, in which the genetic locus is on the short arm of chromosome 4, fibroblast growth factor receptor 3 gene.⁶

Bracing is the standard practice until skeletal maturity or until spinal fusion is feasible as there is a high rate of non-union when anterior and posterior fusion of spine is attempted. In one of the largest long-term follow-up study over a 37-year period of 11 patients (ranging from 20 weeks of gestation to age 70 years), it was shown that the progression of the thoracic kyphosis in this condition is relentless and resistant to surgical treatment, leading researchers to conclude that surgery is unlikely to alter the long term outcome in such patients.⁴ Other causes of morbidity include cervical instability leading to myelopathy, hearing loss, upper respiratory obstruction secondary to laryngo-tracheal dysfunction and functional impairments resulting from degenerative joint deformity, especially teratologic hip dislocations which may be bilateral.^4-10

In contrast, our patient showed marked improvement in thoraco-lumbar kyphoscoliosis following corrective spine surgery (multifocal osteotomies and posterior stabilization with fusion) over a period of 6 years as a result of addressing the case early during the growth period of the spine. Limb length discrepancy and deformity was managed with timely intervention and hemiepiphysiodesis.

Conclusion

If corrective surgery is performed at an appropriate time after careful patient selection and preoperative evaluation, especially of the pulmonary function, the progression of deformity can be halted and the patient can be encouraged to a live normal life. Surgery for short stature is to be decided on per case basis, according to the severity of deformities which are progressive in due course of time. Understanding the clinical spectrum of metatropic dysplasia, careful patient selection and appropriate intervention has great potential for functional improvement and hence, leading an independent social life for these challenging cases.

Acknowledgements

The authors report no conflict of interest and no funding was received for this work.

References

 1. Maroteaux P, Spranger JW, Wiedemann HR. [Metatrophic dwarfism]. Arch Kinderheilkd 1966 Feb;173(3):211-226.

2. Beck M, Roubicek M, Rogers JG, Naumoff P, Spranger J. Heterogeneity of metatropic dysplasia. Eur J Pediatr 1983 Jun-Jul;140(3):231-237.

3. Geneviève D, Le Merrer M, Feingold J, Munnich A, Maroteaux P, Cormier-Daire V. Revisiting metatropic dysplasia: presentation of a series of 19 novel patients and review of the literature. Am J Med Genet A 2008 Apr;146A(8):992-996.

4. Kannu P, Aftimos S, Mayne V, Donnan L, Savarirayan R. Metatropic dysplasia: clinical and radiographic findings in 11 patients demonstrating long-term natural history. Am J Med Genet A 2007 Nov;143A(21):2512-2522.

5. Krakow D, Vriens J, Camacho N, Luong P, Deixler H, Funari TL, et al. Mutations in the gene encoding the calcium-permeable ion channel TRPV4 produce spondylometaphyseal dysplasia, Kozlowski type and metatropic dysplasia. Am J Hum Genet 2009 Mar;84(3):307-315.

6. Naveen NS, Murlimanju BV, Kumar V, Pulakunta T, Jeeyar H, Jeeyar H, et al; Jeeyar H. Thanatophoric dysplasia: a rare entity. Oman Med J 2011 May;26(3):196-197.

7. Boden SD, Kaplan FS, Fallon MD, Ruddy R, Belik J, Anday E, et al. Metatropic dwarfism. Uncoupling of endochondral and perichondral growth. J Bone Joint Surg Am 1987 Feb;69(2):174-184.

8. Akhter S, Rahman S, Momen M, Karim M, Kawser C. Metatropic dysplasia in children. Mymensingh Med J 2008 Jan;17(1):93-97.

9. Wada A, Fujii T, Takamura K, Yanagida H, Urano N, Baba M. Operative treatment of bilateral hip dislocations in a child with metatropic dysplasia. J Pediatr Orthop B 2007 Mar;16(2):94-97.